Professors - Evaluate Your Teaching Effectiveness - Arrange Informal Assessments by Colleagues

Woo-hee! This is a scary concept - having a colleague5. Define, as specifically as possibly, what you want
come in to your classroom to observe your teachingthe other person to 'look for.' If no direction is
(and then to give you feedback). I know it'sprovided, then the feedback you may receive could
intimidating (for a lot of reasons), but I'm going toend up being less than helpful. In addition, the other
write about it anyway and encourage you to accessperson may feel like a ship adrift when walking into
this as a feedback method. Here are some ideas toyour classroom and in fact, feel less confident that if
keep in mind when you considering inviting someonethe direction had been provided.
to observe you as you teach.6. Discuss the ways that the observer could make
First, think about who you might ask. You could invitenotes, depending on his/her style as well as whether
- An experienced instructor in your own departmentor not you have a particular form you want used. In
- whom you know well.many cases, I felt most comfortable using a laptop
- An experienced instructor in your own departmentwhere I could script nearly everything that was said,
- whom you don't know well, other than bymuch faster than I could have hand written it (plus,
reputation.with a laptop, at least someone could read it later!!)
- An experienced instructor in another department -7. Set up a time when the two of you can debrief.
whom you know well.Note: The debrief is better sooner rather than later in
- An experienced instructor in another department -terms of making sure that memories are still intact
whom you don't know well, other than by reputation.about what happened in the classroom interactions.
- Someone who has been assigned as a peer mentor.Note that there is significant risk in this process
- Someone who has been assigned as anunless you are absolutely comfortable with the
experienced faculty mentor.person observing your teaching and that person,
- Someone from your institution's faculty teachinglikewise, is comfortable playing this role. If the person
learning center (or one of their specially-trainedyou chose declines - for perfectly understandable
faculty consultants).reasons - resist applying pressure of any kind. The
- A graduate student from your department (or ansimple fact that you invited him or her to participate
undergraduate student from your department (orin the process might plant a seed that will bear fruit
another one).at some later time. Note too that an informal
There are many ways to set up the observation, butassessment may be especially useful when there is a
here are a few guidelines:formal process in place that you must satisfy later -
your colleague's observation can serve as a trial run.
1. Ask the person if s/he would be willing to observeTherefore arrange it far enough advance so that you
your teaching and provide you with feedback. If thehave time to make changes based upon its feedback.
answer is yes, proceed. If no, thank the person andHaving a colleague observe your classroom and give
assure that there are "no worries."you feedback is invaluable - regardless of whether
2. Determine a time that is mutually convenient foryou are an outstanding teacher or someone who is
the two of you.struggling a bit. I won essentially every award
3. Discuss the expectation of confidentiality - both foravailable at my institution and had observers
your students' sakes as well as yours.constantly - and it helped me. AND, sometimes, I
4. Provide whatever background information theasked observers to attend my class because I was
other person might need about your teaching, thestruggling with an entire class or a whole group. It
particular lesson you're teaching, the students in thewas always scary - and always helpful, too. Don't
class, and any other pertinent context.miss this chance for growth.